Manaflask Article

Flex Raiding Q&A

Can I run a Flex raid with 10 rogues and zero healers and zero tanks?

It doesn't change the mechanics of what raids are, it's a variable difficulty that scales on the number of people you have. You'll still need tanks, you'll still need healers, and you'll still need DPS; the fundamental archetypes of the game aren't changing.

If your guild or group of friends isn't attempting raids now outside of LFR, you might have some roles you're not filling, but you certainly could get to that point. Certainly expect people to be building PUGs and such, but that's not really the intended target. The immediately intended target of Flex is to allow the more casual guilds that are already making small attempts at Normal (and probably hit a brick wall early on in ToT) to more easily get weekly groups together to have fun and progress on content that's more suited for their pace. They want to see the content, want some challenge in progressing, but aren't so hardcore as to be sitting people out or demanding requirements of those playing. Jump in and play the game with friends, have fun, low stress, Flex.

I hope it helps with reviving the pugging scene I met a lot of friends that way.

Absolutely. Just the process of people putting groups together for things and having that need for some coordination in the content, you end up seeing the same people over and over, make friends, and that in no small part helps to build long-term in-game relationships and feeds into healthy guilds.

So if a 10 man raid group thats casually doing Normal modes decides to do a flex raid, its just plain easier. no doubts there.
But if they bring their 10 man, and then 5 more healer friends, how does it scale? Just plain scaling of the bosses HP? wouldn't it mean those 5 other healer friends are kind of dead weight?

If you're thinking strictly in terms of "what is optimal for us to complete this content efficiently" then Flex is probably not targeted at you.

Balancing will come out during the PTR though, I don't think we'll get into how it'll scale too much before then. It'll err on the side of the group, and ensuring they can meaningfully progress in a reasonable amount of time.

But only 25m casual groups or 10m groups with large rosters, right? A small, casual 10m group that ends up missing people on a given night won't really be able to take advantage of the flex system to "just raid anyway" with their friends, which I think is a shame.
I'd love to see a little more flex allowing for maybe 8-28 raiders or something, so that 25m groups can also take advantage of the new flex raids to not have to bench friends, and 10m groups can worry less about having their raid night cancelled because of one or two missing raiders.

Raid mechanics start to break down when you go much below 10 players. There are still assumptions of having 2 tanks and 2 healers, and some mechanics are not really able to scale with much fewer DPS. Raids are still going to be raids, and raids are designed with some 'givens' to ensure the mechanics can be interesting, complex, and challenging.

But unlike Normal and Heroic, you CAN invite BattleTag/RealID friends to a Flex raid of the current tier, and so if you're short you can fill it out with people you know, instead of spamming chat to pick up randoms.

The designers are discussing allowing you to at least enter the raid with 8+ people. The intent would be to allow a group to start clearing trash while they wait for a couple stragglers, as the difficulty with less than 10 would still be scaled for 10. It could allow for skilled/geared players to do it with less than 10, but some mechanics just may not be possible as we're not designing for it.

Can they leave and have the raid automatically adjust on the fly? How about adding people after it starts?

Yes, and yes. It's dynamic.

How is it going to scale for healers? If I'm taking 17 players how will I know how many healers I will need?

You'll still want a standard raiding DPS/Healer ratio. It doesn't look at class or spec, it's purely scaling for number of players. It'll be up to the raid leader, and depending on gear and skill it'll be different for every group of people how much they can really deviate and how those deviations affect their rate of progression.

Again, it's going to be up to the PTR and seeing how testing progresses to determine how balancing shakes out and what's possible.

We just made tech which could made life of 25-men a lot easier. Let's give it to LFR folks. -.-

This isn’t for LFR folks, it’s for Normal folks (ahem... you know what I mean) that were going into LFR and weren’t having an enjoyable raiding experience or that just wanted an easy way to play with friends and family without spending too much time organizing it. These players would go to LFR only for gear, not for the experience, and that’s not really what we want to see happening.

I’m hoping that players who are looking for more challenging content, but have no time to get into the usual guild raiding schedules, will start to switch from LFR to Flexible Raids.

Highly skilled players with heavy time constraints have always felt a bit left out from MMORPGs, but maybe there are ways we can deal with that.

Ideally, skill should be equally or even better rewarded than time, but there needs to be a balance between the two, we can’t provide 30 minutes of insanely difficult content with the best rewards that only 0.001% of the player base would be able reach, but we also can’t do the opposite and make rewards exclusively and directly proportional with time spent. Skill needs to enter into the equation and needs to have a pretty strong weight.

LFR still has its own place, some players are quite content with it, some have no intention of going any further than LFR in terms of raiding and are happy with the experience it provides. We’re just trying to provide content for everyone to enjoy.

This is just a preview, 5.4 isn’t even on the PTR yet, many things can still change. This is also part of the reason why we’re sharing this information with you all; the feedback we get will help us to better shape our next major content patch. I've already seen quite a few interesting and unexpected arguments in this thread and we'll share them with the devs, so keep it up!

With a new raid lockout things will indeed change (not for everyone, of course). If you want to stay ahead and on the top of your game, you'd want to run both the 5.4 LFR and LFR+ since they most likely will wield upgrades, whether it be because you want to mixmax for your normal/heroic raid progress or because you want to see your character evolve.

That’s a good point, I believe that a few players might do that for a little while, but I would like to point out that the unlocking of Flexible Raids and LFR are very similar but on different timetables, this will probably mean that normal and heroic will open first, then FR and then LFR.

So by the time LFR opens, chances are, there won’t be that many upgrades left for let’s say, a fully heroic equipped 5.3 raider, which is the typical player that usually tries to get upgrades wherever and whenever possible.

I think it's an amazing idea, but I would like to see it 8-25 or 5-25 if possible + make the loot the same ilvl as normal and make flexi and normal share the lockout, or even replace the whole normal with 8-25 mode.
If there are 11-12 one night, the guild has to decide to do the low ilvl with all players, or do the high ilvl but 1-2 are left out.. and i'm almost positive they will choose the higher ilvl.

Yes that will probably happen to some extent in some groups, but that will depend on how hard the content really turns out to be and the ilvl difference between those “extra” players and the rest.
So, yes, it’s possible that some groups form with the intent to be as efficient as possible, so those will only include the best geared players in the smallest possible group.

I don’t think we should worry too much about that to be honest, in the end it’s all up to whoever organizes the raid, and that has always been the case. I sincerely doubt that most groups will leave people behind just for a small difference in terms of item level. Besides, ilvl isn’t everything, every guild decides on whom to bring to the raids based on many different factors, gear is only one of them, there’s skill, there’s personality, there’s knowledge…

Then let us assign loot to players whilst doing it please. One of my initial thoughts about this was it would be a useful way to help undergeared (whether through bad luck, absence due to real-life, or because they are trailists that need a little boost in ilevel) team members improve their gear.
Then I read that this new difficulty would be using the current lfr loot roll system. This would be a hindrance to such help. It would be useful if this decision were reconsidered, so that raiding guilds could assign gear to members based on need for helping us progress through normal's and heroic's.

There's nothing that cannot be reconsidered and iterated before a patch goes live, we'll share your input about the loot system with the devs.

Sorry, but I don't see that the traditional loot distribution would work with flexible raid size. If they add brackets to how many items drop based in a fixed amount of people (ie 2 with 10, 3 with 15, 4 with 20, 5 with 25) people would just pick enough people to reach that.

That’s a very good point; I assume that's probably the reason why this loot system was chosen in the first place. But like I said, everything is still subject to change, devs sometimes like to surprise us with unexpected solutions.

  1. included1's avatar
    included1 2015-09-10 01:01:23 UTC — To SSD (solid state drive) programming (1): Introduction and table of contents for Nike Nike Hyperdunk 2013 Free Run Nike Hyperdunk 2014 2 the SSD program (2): architecture and benchmarks SSD for SSD program Nike Barkley Posite Max (3): p, block and flash translation Michael Kors Outlet Nike Air Max 2014 Women layer SSD program (4): Advanced features and internal parallel in the previous section, I described the inner workings of most SSDs, I can provide data to help understand what Nike Air Max 2015 kind of access mode should together why this model is indeed better than others to use. Nike Air Max 95 In this section, Nike Hyperchaos Shoes 2013 I explain how to complete the write and read, and write Michael Kors Crossbody Bags and Michael Kors Wallets read concurrent interfere with each other. I Nike Free Run also introduced the file system level that can enhance performance optimization. Nike Air Max 2014 Men 7. Access Mode 7.1 define sequential and random I / O operations in the next Nike Air Max 2015 Men section, I'm going from 'order' or 'random' to start. If the logical block address I / O operation is started Michael Kors Nike Air Zoom Flight The Glove Shoulder Bags (LBA) directly followed the last LBA before an I / O operation is Nike Air Max 2015 Women Nike Lunar 2015 Nike Free 5.0 called sequential access. If not, then the I / O operation is Michael Kors Satchels called random access. This is very important point, because FTL performs dynamic mapping, adjacent logical address space may be used in non-contiguous physical address space. 7.2 write benchmark and the manufacturer's data sheet Michael Kors Hobo shows that random writes slower than the Nike Free Womens write sequence, but this is not always right, because the random write speeds really depends on the type of workload. If writing relatively small, say less than the cluster (translation: an article on the translation of the cluster see) size (that is, \u0026 lt; 32MB), Nike Air Yeezy II then yes, slower random write than sequential writes. However, if the random writes are aligned according to the cluster size, and sequential write performance will be the same. He explained below. As mentioned in section VI, SSD internal parallelism Nike Free TR Fit by parallel and staggered to allow simultaneous access to the Michael Kors Totes cluster of blocks. Therefore, whether random or sequence is written, it will be the same to write data to Nike Air Max a plurality of channels and the chip, thereby performing the cluster size is written to ensure that all of the internal parallel use both. Write operations on the cluster Nike Free Run Womens will be explained in the back of 7.3. As shown Michael Kors Clutches in performance, such as from [2] and [8] in FIG. 8 and FIG. 9. When benchmarking write cache and cluster size (mostly SSD is 16 or 32MB) same or greater, random write and sequential writes Nike Free Run 3 achieve the same high throughput. Figure 8: 4 SSD sequential write and random write load efficiency load Air Jordan Outlet control - according to Kim et al, 2012 [2] re-mapping 9: 3 SSD sequential write and random write load load efficiency control - in accordance with Min et al, 2012 [8] remake, however, if it is written small - smaller than the NAND flash page refers to small, that is \u0026 lt.;
  2. supplier73's avatar
    supplier73 2015-08-11 07:53:34 UTC — We as a software engineer responsibilities
    English text: Nike Air Max 90 Honeycomb Women the responsibility we have as software engineers this week I had the honor and very good Kate Heddleston together, she mentioned Jordan CP3 VI class="category-top">Air Jordan Heels that she had recently done a lot of software engineers on ethical reflection, she only talked about part of PyCon Sweden Conference. It reminds me of a few years ago I wrote an article, Nike Air Max 90 Hyperfuse (Women Nike Air Jordan I mentioned that: There is a continuing and alarmingly spread the illusion that technology is more or less neutral, ethical Nike Air Max decision is to do for others out. But this is not true. Lessig taught me (and generation of technical experts), the code that the law [Note 1] [\u0026 hellip;] In 2008, the World has turned banker, because a lot of revenue through rapid growth areas (financial instruments [Note 2]) to expand their expertise, which is built on top Air Max for Women of other people even basic concepts (adjustable rate mortgages) are not sure of. Our software engineers also need more time to find our expertise in a similar position? And other experts in the field as the same, experts Nike Air Max 90 Hyperfuse (Women in the field, our responsibility is to guide the other person that they make the best decision, then we have to make our own responsibility to avoid this Nike Air Max when? Well, I think it is time. Everyone uses the software, but very few people understand it. For small elite group is very obvious stuff, but completely let most of the world was blurred. This gap in our software engineering elite, it is very, very difficult to see. A few examples: Radiolab Podcast website posted a nice video \u0026 mdash; \u0026 mdash; 'Trust Engineers' \u0026 mdash; \u0026 mdash; the video discusses the Facebook operation of their sources [Note 3] experimental conditions. For non-engineers, providing people Nike Zoom KD with information daily algorithm, by a group of people living, too much control, aware of this, it will James Harden produce an incredible, live up to the feeling of trust. (In this regard, and for those who are accustomed to dealing with the review committee researchers, for Facebook has done is completely Nike Air Max 2015 Men shocked.) For most engineers, including Facebook considerable part of good, ethical people, including, \u0026 ldquo; This is even regarded as a problem \u0026 rdquo; in itself is amazing. Years ago, a friend of a friend, who happens to be the world's leading physicians Nike Air Max 95 Men and researchers, he asked Nike Basketball me: \u0026 JORDAN ldquo; Ben, the work of system administrators to read my email? Even if they do not Air Max for Men have my password? \u0026 Rdquo; the answer is too right. This is our engineer, is clear enough, so do not even think about us. For non-engineers, and even very smart people, this is absolutely obvious. A Nike Air Max 95 Women good friend, and a wise man, and his children are to discuss some things, I overheard a word \u0026 ldquo; if you do not Nike Air Max 95 class="category-top">D Rose IV know, just ask the computer, the computer knows, and it's always right. \u0026 Rdquo; I do? Our software engineers have the most far unable to understand Nike Air Max 90 Hyperfuse (Women superpower. Hope our trust and social development so fast, that the only place to Nike Shoes Nike Zoom Shoes Global look somewhat similar to that of a doctor who trust sustenance. Unless, when most people their trust in the hands of a doctor who has a deep understanding, but they almost do not know, every time they install an app, enter some personal data, or share Jordan B'Mo intimate thoughts in the privacy of electronic communications, they are a trust group of software engineers, and the engineers of ethical guidelines for the form of poorly understood. Our Hippocratic Oath [Note 4] where we are \u0026 ldquo; First of all, do not hurt Lebron James Shoes people? \u0026 Rdquo; where? In my own work, I try to think hard about this thing, I try to deal with my guidance, and each engineer to share this responsibility. I'm still not the best answer to the core issues. However, Nike Air Max 2015 Women for us, to find out it Nike Blazers is becoming increasingly urgent and important. Note 1: The power of the framework is here, this is the designer can decide what is allowed, what is essentially to prohibit. If designers do not Nike Air Max 90 Hyperfuse (Women want to let something happen, then the magic from the API function calls disappear. If designers like the idea, so there is usually more than one Nike Shoes function call, and many support tools. This is Harvard Law School professor Larry Lessig why I like to say \u0026 ldquo; code or Cheap Nike Free Outlet law \u0026 rdquo; reasons., can also refer to .22Code_is_law.22 Note 2: Financial instruments (English: Financial instruments) is a contract in the financial markets so that lenders hold contracts an asset, and make debit holders who become liabilities, such as bonds, stocks, options, hedge funds, deposits certificate so the case, the definition of No. 39 in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards. The only difference in the specific terms of his contract and the nature of classification, interest payment period, preservation, can change different stocks, cash flow, etc.. Note 3: Source (English: web feed, news feed, syndicated feed also translated source material, feeding, provision of information, feeds, abstracts, Air Jordan Outlet source, news feeds, network source) is a data format that can be transmitted to the user site through which the latest information, users can subscribe to the site is a prerequisite Web site provides continually updated information. SOURCE widespread use blog and news site, because this type of site is frequently updated content. Note 4: The Hippocratic Oath, commonly known physician oath, is Western doctors oath before practice traditionally, is the ancient Greek healer Hippocrates, known as the Western \u0026 ldquo; \u0026 rdquo ;, the father of medicine in the Hippocratic oath which they made this, list some specific ethical Standard. % A9% 9E Translation: 'We as a software engineer to assume responsibility,' Laba
  3. smile's avatar
    smile 2015-05-21 07:43:36 UTC — Send another 475 US troops to Iraq

    People Power September 11 local time the evening of 10 September, US President Obama to combat extremist organizations Obama called on Congress to authorize the training Syrian armed opposition, and provide them with weapons program, to support their fight against Obama said, expand, he said, against the full range of combat oakley frogskins ISIS program in three stages

    According to Singapore's 'Lianhe Zaobao' Network September 9 reported that senior US officials said US President Barack Obama prepared occhiali oakley prezzi for at least three years to implement a national organization plans to destroy Islam. Reportedly, Obama will be announced on the 10th in a nationally televised speech in the United States is likely to continue to take the lead after his term strategy. Obama has said on the 7th, programs to combat Islamic State organizations will cover the multiple dimensions of economic, political and military.

    report quoted the US 'New York Times' reported that Obama this three-year plan in three phases. The first stage is the US air strikes had begun. In the past month, the United States launched against Iraq has nearly 145 air raids, intended to protect local minorities, US diplomatic, intelligence and military personnel and their facilities, while preventing the Islamic State organizations to continue oakley outlet online in northern and western Iraq expand their influence.

    second stage, after the new coalition government in Iraq this week, oakley occhiali da vista more inclusive organization, stepping up the Iraqi army, Kurdish fighters and even some Sunni tribal militias to provide training and weapons.
    The last stage of the plan
    the most difficult, but also the most occhiali sole oakley controversial, and that is to destroy the Iraqi State Organization Syria. US Defense Department officials believe that this military action will continue for at least 36 months, that is to say, this crackdown may not be completed at the end of Obama's term of office.

    US Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel said recently that the United States has constructed aimed at eliminating the occhiali oakley prezzi ISIS reported that US Secretary of State Warren 9th trip to the Middle occhiali oakley prezzi East. In London, published in Arabic, 'Middle East News' reported that Kerry's trip targeted According oakley frogskins scontati to Saudi official media reports, Egypt, Jordan, Turkey, and the foreign ministers of all six Gulf Arab countries will meet with Christopher in Jeddah.
  4. Sil's avatar
    Sil 2013-06-08 22:43:13 UTC — This is a logical move in the way that they are trying to reach an even larger public and attract the already playing public to keep raiding. They are trying not to affect the hardcore "core", or what's left of it by using the argument that raiding with 25 players is still possible if they want to do so. Which in essence of course is true. From Blizzard's and the large public point of view this might be a good move and it might not be. But for the people that love raiding I think this has been the worst change in the history of WoW. This move has probably been done hoping to extend's WoW's lifespan due to recent news about 'Titan' delay, if I'd have to guess.
  5. DarnnREM's avatar
    DarnnREM 2013-06-08 22:28:14 UTC — @Lagruell I know I'm not the target for Flex , althought I think in it's current form it will do potentially even more dmg to the game. I also agree with @Exaltus that going back to Vanilla-style system would fail miserably nowadays, but some kind of attunement would be nice.

    Preach, guy from that 90 to Lei Shen vid, had an interesting idea how to redesign LFR and whole catch-up mechanic. T14 LFR would be unlocked after the release of T15, so alts and players that are casual would have an easier way to get geared for newest content/see the raid. T15 LFR would be released with the T16 normal and so on.

    Now imagine this scenario after introducing Flex. Flex replaces LFR and is released togheter with normal and heroic mode at the same time. For the most casual players, Flex would be the way to go. For more serious guilds we would have normal mode to let them gear up first before attempting heroics. The top notch guilds competing for WF ranks would save immense amount of time by going straight for hc mode - no more running 6 25mans to funnel gear etc, whole alt style of raiding would be greatly diminished. Possibility of some random guild getting WF on hc boss before the big boys imo doesn't really exist, and even if so - they wouldn't be able to get WF on last boss of the tier on hc.

    When whole progression would be over, after the release of minor patch without raiding content, LFR would get unlocked to gear up alts, or catch up with legendary quest and please people that would want to just get carried.
  6. Lagruell's avatar
    Lagruell 2013-06-08 19:30:37 UTC — @Michelangelo: LFR and Flex are gated to avoid having competitive guilds doing this. It should work if they aren't unlocked too quickly.
  7. Michelangelo's avatar
    Michelangelo 2013-06-08 19:24:29 UTC — So long as you can acquire tier tokens, trinkets, and weapons, all raid lockouts will be used by a player to stay competitive.

    T13 lfr loot was lower ilvl than T12 heroic but T13 set bonuses were too important for some classes. With respect to "people won't think it's mandatory since there won't be upgrades" I highly disagree.
  8. Lagruell's avatar
    Lagruell 2013-06-08 19:22:06 UTC — I think this type of raid should perfectly fit its target, it isn't meant for you Darniee, but it might help the game not to lose too much subscriptions, thus improving your experience.

    There are people who just don't like to get to sit on the bench, be it for a week, or a particular encounter. There are people who just can't stand cancelling a raid because someone didn't show up.

    Also, raiding hasn't always been about skill but dedication and free time (farming, optimizing, learning from wipes...), and from that should come skill. Some people are just as dedicated as you are, but they don't have your free time.
  9. Exaltus's avatar
    Exaltus 2013-06-08 14:06:12 UTC — Though i agree with what you say Darniee, a compromise like this will keep a lot more people playing the game, and thus a lot more funds will be free to make better raids (imo ToT was one of the best raids in WoW so far). I'm afraid if wow would turn back to its roots in vanilla and tbc now, even more people would abandon it. But i also think if it stays like it is now (with LFR for the casuals), these casual players won't have any sense of accomplishment and they'll leave as well. So this flexible system might be a good middle of the road solution. They get to feel 'real raiding' in a very flexible way, but still don't get the same rewards for it.
  10. DarnnREM's avatar
    DarnnREM 2013-06-08 12:20:48 UTC — I'm still not convinced to this idea at all. Raiding was about skill. If you were not skilled enough to raid, you either were benched or didn't raid at all. You had simple choice to either pick up your gameplay or go pvp f.e. I understand the fact that some people were not pleased with it and they started "accesibility" argument. But where is the accomplishement here? Is it really something to kill boss with let's say 12 people, boss with skill requirement close to LFR rather than normal? Kind of paraolympic games.